Need help?Jamie

AI Search

What a Monthly AI SEO Report Should Show You

Paying monthly for AI SEO and getting a report you can't act on? A good report says what was done, what each number means and what to decide next. A dashboard of impressions, screenshots and a vendor's own visibility score fails if nobody can say where the numbers came from.

Illustration of a marketing search strategy workspace.

See how I'd approach this

Choose a question
to look at with me.

From a useful page to a relevant searchUseful websiteRelevant discoveryCRAWL · UNDERSTAND · CONNECT
  1. Useful website
  2. Crawl and understand the page
  3. Connect it to a relevant search
From a useful page to a relevant search

Use this structure to judge any AI SEO services report, ours included. Trojan Digital Marketing is based in Indianapolis and offers SEO, AEO and GEO work to local service businesses. When Jeff Clerisier, our founder, works out a scope, we'd agree what counts as a qualified inquiry before any work starts. Bring your latest report: the first strategy call is free, and during business hours we aim to reply within five minutes.

Lead with the decision the owner needs to make

Make account access explicitYourbusinessDomainWebsiteAnalyticsRecords
Domain and website
Document ownership and access.
Analytics and records
Define access and the handover.
Make account access explicitDomain, website, analytics and customer records need clear ownership and a workable handover.

We'd open the report with the current recommendation and the reason for it. The business may need to clarify a service page, fix an inquiry path, expand a useful comparison, or continue collecting evidence. State what changed since the last review and what remains uncertain.

This does not require hiding detail. Put the source evidence and definitions behind the recommendation so they can be inspected. The report should work both for an owner who needs the decision and for a team member who needs to reproduce the analysis.

Show completed work with a verifiable record

List the pages, settings, or workflows changed and explain the purpose of each change. Include the approval or release date and the acceptance condition. “Published four articles” is less useful than identifying the buyer decisions those articles answer and the evidence used to approve their claims.

Separate completed work from drafts, recommendations awaiting approval, and blocked dependencies. A proposed fix is not an implemented fix. If another vendor must make the change, name the dependency and the information needed to proceed.

The audit scope article provides a finding format that can carry through into this implementation record.

Keep platform reporting within its definitions

Google's Search generative AI report documents AI impression reporting and available dimensions. Bing's June 2026 AI visibility update describes additional reporting features including intents, topics, citation share, and comparison. Each platform counts in its own way.

We keep their numbers apart and never blend them into one unnamed score. Preserve the source, date range, filters, and definitions. Explain whether data is available for the property and whether a reporting change affects comparison with earlier periods. A missing report should be marked unavailable, not replaced with a different source under the same label.

Describe monitoring samples honestly

If the retainer includes manual or third party prompt monitoring, show the question set, relevant settings, collection dates, and coverage. Distinguish a business mention from a linked citation and a factual error from an absence. Preserve unavailable observations separately from negative ones.

A trend within a monitored sample can inform investigation. It does not measure every customer's experience or establish market wide visibility. If the sample changes, report the change so readers do not mistake a new measurement setup for a business improvement.

The citation evidence audit playbook can help turn notable observations into specific corrections and destination improvements.

Connect the website experience to inquiry quality

Report recorded website activity using the site's actual analytics configuration. Identify relevant landing pages, contact actions, and known collection limitations. Keep source definitions stable where possible, and record changes to forms, tracking, consent behavior, or phone routing.

Then report business outcomes using agreed definitions. A qualified inquiry should mean something consistent to the sales team. Separate spam, duplicates, and existing customer requests when the process supports it. Do not present every form submission as a new sales opportunity.

Our AI automation service can support reviewable intake and handoffs, but the qualification rule still needs an accountable business owner. Uncertain messages should remain reviewable instead of receiving a confident label by default.

Explain changes without overstating causation

Use the change log to place observations in context. A revised service page, a new offer, a seasonal shift, an advertising change, and an operational staffing change can all affect the period. State the known events before crediting the outcome to one change. Our own network shows why: 204 Indiana water restoration microsites logged 17 calls and form inquiries in July and August 2026, missed calls excluded. Eleven came during the August floods, so we'd never credit that month to a page edit.

When evidence is thin, we say so in plain words: the pattern is encouraging, the cause is uncertain, or the sample is too small to compare. Then name the next check. Uncertainty should lead to a practical investigation or a measured decision to wait, rather than a vague disclaimer at the end of the report.

Report maintenance and ownership as part of the service

Include important factual updates, retired content, unresolved source conflicts, and review obligations. Show whether the business can access its accounts and export the records it needs. Month after month, the work should leave records anyone can follow, so the business never depends on one person's memory.

The proposal comparison guide explains how to establish these expectations before signing. The reporting process should then demonstrate that the agreed ownership and handoff arrangements are working.

Finish with a small, accountable work plan

Make the report reproducible enough for a handoff

Store the source exports, metric dictionary, processing notes and dated recommendations in a location the business can access. A future employee or provider should be able to understand what was measured and why a decision was made. This does not require exposing confidential internal software; it requires preserving the business evidence and agreed deliverables.

When definitions change, keep the previous definition with the historical period. If a lead qualification rule becomes stricter, a decline in qualified inquiries may partly reflect that change. If a monitoring provider expands its sample, a visibility trend may no longer be directly comparable. We'd rather explain the break than smooth it away, because a tidy chart built from mismatched measures misleads anyone who plans from it.

Finally, identify who maintains each collection step so a broken integration or abandoned CRM field does not quietly undermine the next review.

List the next actions, the evidence behind them, their owners, and the condition that will trigger review. Avoid carrying a long undifferentiated backlog into every monthly meeting. Distinguish necessary repairs from content opportunities and experiments.

The AI search reporting playbook offers a fuller operating process. Ask Trojan Digital Marketing to review your retainer reporting needs if the current report is difficult to connect to decisions. Bring the definitions, source exports, and current scope so the discussion can focus on what the business actually needs to know.

Sources & further reading

Need our help with this on your own site?

Request a free strategy call

The first strategy call is free, and during business hours we aim to reply within five minutes.